The Safest Caribbean Island To Live In 2023

The Caribbean is known for its beautiful beaches, vibrant culture, and relaxing atmosphere. However, crime rates can vary greatly between different islands. If safety is your top concern when looking for a Caribbean home, this article will explore the safest islands to live on in 2023.

If you’re short on time, here’s a quick answer: The Cayman Islands rank as the overall safest Caribbean island due to low crime rates, political stability, developed infrastructure, and advanced disaster preparedness.

Throughout this article, we will compare crime statistics, disaster risk, infrastructure quality, health care access, and other livability factors to determine the top 5 safest Caribbean islands for living in 2023.

We will also overview pros and cons, cost of living, visa options, and quality of life considerations for each destination.

Cayman Islands

Low Crime Rates

The Cayman Islands is widely regarded as one of the safest Caribbean islands to live in. With a low crime rate, residents can enjoy a sense of security and peace of mind. The local government has implemented strict measures to maintain law and order, making it a desirable destination for individuals and families alike.

According to data from the Royal Cayman Islands Police Service, the crime rate in the Cayman Islands has consistently remained low over the years, with a focus on community policing and crime prevention initiatives.

Political Stability

Another reason why the Cayman Islands is a safe place to live is its strong political stability. The islands have a stable government and a well-established legal system, ensuring the protection of citizens’ rights and maintaining a peaceful environment.

The Cayman Islands Government operates under a constitutional framework, providing stability and security for residents and businesses. This political stability has contributed to the overall safety and well-being of the community.

Developed Infrastructure

The Cayman Islands boast a developed infrastructure that further enhances its safety. The islands have well-maintained roads, modern healthcare facilities, and reliable public services. The government continually invests in infrastructure development, ensuring that residents have access to essential amenities and services.

This commitment to infrastructure development contributes to the overall safety and convenience of living in the Cayman Islands.

Hurricane Preparedness

Living in a hurricane-prone region, such as the Caribbean, requires careful consideration of safety measures. The Cayman Islands have robust hurricane preparedness plans in place, including early warning systems, evacuation protocols, and well-equipped emergency response teams.

The government and local authorities prioritize the safety of residents and visitors during hurricane seasons, ensuring that everyone is well-prepared and protected in the event of a storm. These measures contribute to the overall safety and resilience of the Cayman Islands.

High Cost of Living

While the Cayman Islands offer numerous advantages in terms of safety and quality of life, it is essential to consider the high cost of living associated with residing in this Caribbean paradise. The islands’ popularity as a tax haven and tourism destination has driven up the prices of goods, services, and real estate.

It is important to carefully plan and budget for the higher expenses associated with living in the Cayman Islands. However, many residents find that the benefits of safety and security outweigh the higher cost of living.


Barbados is often regarded as one of the safest Caribbean islands to live in. With its beautiful beaches, vibrant culture, and welcoming community, it has become an attractive destination for individuals and families seeking a safe and secure place to call home.

Moderate Crime Levels

Barbados has relatively low crime rates compared to other Caribbean islands. The local government and law enforcement agencies have made significant efforts to ensure the safety of residents and visitors.

While petty theft and pickpocketing can still occur in crowded tourist areas, violent crimes are rare. It is always advisable to take common-sense precautions, such as locking doors and securing valuables, to minimize any potential risks.

Stable Government

Barbados boasts a stable government and a well-functioning democracy. With a long history of political stability and peaceful transitions of power, residents can feel confident in the country’s governance.

The government’s commitment to maintaining law and order contributes to the overall safety and security of the island.

High-Quality Health Care

Barbados offers excellent health care services, making it an ideal destination for those concerned about their well-being. The island is home to modern medical facilities and highly trained healthcare professionals.

The government has made significant investments in the healthcare sector, ensuring access to quality medical services for both residents and visitors.

Prone to Hurricanes

As with many Caribbean islands, Barbados is prone to hurricanes during the Atlantic hurricane season, which typically runs from June to November. While the island has robust disaster preparedness measures in place, it is essential for residents to stay informed about weather conditions and follow any evacuation orders issued by authorities.

Being prepared for potential hurricanes is crucial for ensuring the safety of individuals and their property.

Relatively Expensive

While Barbados offers a high standard of living and a safe environment, it is important to note that it can be relatively expensive compared to other Caribbean destinations. The cost of housing, utilities, and everyday essentials may be higher than in some neighboring countries.

However, the island’s strong economy and high quality of life make it a worthwhile investment for those seeking a safe and secure place to live.


If you’re considering relocating to the Caribbean and safety is your top priority, look no further than Anguilla. With its reputation for being one of the safest islands in the region, Anguilla offers residents a peaceful and secure environment to call home.

Very Low Crime

Anguilla boasts an impressively low crime rate, making it an ideal destination for those seeking a safe place to live. The island’s tight-knit community and strong social bonds contribute to the overall sense of security.

Residents can enjoy a laid-back lifestyle without constantly worrying about their safety.

Small Population

One of the key factors contributing to Anguilla’s safety is its small population. With fewer than 15,000 inhabitants, the island has a close-knit community where everyone looks out for each other. This tight community bond creates a sense of security and fosters a crime-free environment.

Lacks Infrastructure

While some may see a lack of infrastructure as a disadvantage, it actually works in Anguilla’s favor when it comes to safety. The island’s limited development means fewer opportunities for crime to occur.

With fewer densely populated areas and less traffic, residents can enjoy a tranquil and secure lifestyle.

Low Hurricane Risk

Living in the Caribbean means being aware of the potential risks posed by hurricanes. Fortunately, Anguilla is located in a region with a relatively low hurricane risk. The island is situated outside the main hurricane belt, reducing the likelihood of being directly hit by a major storm.

This provides residents with peace of mind and eliminates the constant worry associated with hurricane-prone areas.

High-End Real Estate

If you’re looking for a safe place to live that also offers luxurious living options, Anguilla has you covered. The island is known for its high-end real estate market, offering stunning beachfront villas and upscale properties.

With its safe environment and exclusive residential options, Anguilla is an attractive destination for those seeking both security and luxury.

So, if safety is a top priority for you when choosing a Caribbean island to live in, Anguilla should be at the top of your list. Its low crime rate, small population, lack of infrastructure, low hurricane risk, and high-end real estate options make it the ideal place to call home in 2023.


When it comes to finding the safest Caribbean island to live in 2023, look no further than Curaçao. This beautiful island offers a range of benefits that make it an ideal destination for those seeking a secure and peaceful lifestyle.

Lower Violent Crime

Curaçao boasts a significantly lower rate of violent crime compared to other Caribbean islands. The island has implemented effective measures to ensure the safety of its residents, including a well-equipped police force and a strong focus on community engagement.

Visitors and residents alike can enjoy the peace of mind that comes with living in a place with a low crime rate.

Part of Netherlands

One of the unique aspects of Curaçao is its status as a constituent country within the Kingdom of the Netherlands. This affiliation provides Curaçao with access to resources and support from a highly developed nation.

The Dutch influence is evident in the island’s infrastructure, education system, healthcare facilities, and overall standard of living. Residents of Curaçao benefit from the stability and reliability that comes with being part of a larger nation.

Good Transport

Curaçao has a well-developed transportation system, making it easy to get around the island and explore its many attractions. The island has a network of roads that are well-maintained, allowing for smooth and convenient travel.

Additionally, Curaçao has an international airport with regular flights to major destinations, making it easily accessible for both residents and visitors.

Outside Hurricane Belt

Living in Curaçao means enjoying a climate that is outside the traditional hurricane belt. While the Caribbean is known for its tropical storms and hurricanes, Curaçao is located in a region that is less prone to these natural disasters.

This offers residents a sense of security and peace of mind, knowing that they are less likely to be affected by the destructive forces of hurricanes.


Another advantage of living in Curaçao is its affordability. Compared to other Caribbean islands and popular tourist destinations, the cost of living in Curaçao is relatively lower. Housing, utilities, and daily expenses are more affordable, allowing residents to enjoy a comfortable lifestyle without breaking the bank.

This makes Curaçao an attractive option for those looking for a safe and affordable place to call home.

U.S. Virgin Islands

The U.S. Virgin Islands is considered one of the safest Caribbean islands to live in 2023. With its stunning beaches, picturesque landscapes, and warm tropical climate, it attracts many individuals and families seeking a peaceful and secure place to call home.

Moderate Crime Levels

The U.S. Virgin Islands boasts relatively moderate crime levels compared to other Caribbean destinations. While it’s important to remain cautious and take necessary precautions, residents generally feel safe and secure within their communities.

The local authorities work diligently to maintain law and order, ensuring the safety of residents and visitors alike.

U.S. Territory

One of the significant advantages of living in the U.S. Virgin Islands is its status as a U.S. territory. This provides residents with the benefit of being under the protection and jurisdiction of the United States.

The local government operates within the framework of U.S. laws and regulations, offering a sense of stability and security that is highly valued by many.

Decent Infrastructure

The U.S. Virgin Islands has developed a decent infrastructure to support its residents’ daily needs. From reliable transportation systems to healthcare facilities and educational institutions, the islands offer essential services that contribute to a comfortable lifestyle.

The presence of modern amenities and utilities ensures that residents have access to a high standard of living.

Vulnerable to Storms

While the U.S. Virgin Islands may offer a safe living environment, it is important to note that they are vulnerable to storms, including hurricanes. The islands are located in a region prone to tropical weather systems, necessitating preparedness and caution during hurricane seasons.

It is essential for residents to have proper insurance coverage and follow official guidelines to mitigate the risks associated with severe weather events.

High Taxes

One aspect that potential residents should consider when contemplating a move to the U.S. Virgin Islands is the relatively high tax rates. As a U.S. territory, the islands are subject to federal taxes, and additional local taxes may apply.

It is advisable to consult with a financial professional to understand the tax implications and plan accordingly.


In conclusion, while no place is without risk, the Cayman Islands rank as the safest Caribbean island overall thanks to low crime, political stability, strong infrastructure, and proactive disaster planning.

Barbados, Anguilla, Curaçao, and the U.S. Virgin Islands also have favorable safety profiles. Weigh the pros and cons of each to decide the best Caribbean destination to call home.

Similar Posts